House Of Sand And Fog Essay

Kathy finds out how tenuous is the dream of home ownership. Through no fault of her own, she is evicted from her legally owned home by a bureaucratic clerical error (the tax office was seeking payment for the house on Biscove Street, not Bisgrove Street). Although Kathy cannot afford a lawyer, she is assisted by a Legal Aid lawyer, paid for by the state. Although Kathy’s lawyer has filed suit against the county whose tax office made the error, Kathy has nowhere to go after she is evicted and, were it not for Lester’s help, would become homeless. Behrani sees an ad in the legal section of a newspaper for the auction of the Corona house; he gets the house for $45,000, paying in full, first with a $10,000 certified check drawn on the Bank of America and then with cash. Although he moves his family into the house immediately, he plans to sell it and quadruple his investment.

The American Dream and the Rule of LawKathy, who cleans houses for a living, has a competent Legal Aid lawyer (Behrani pays his lawyer $300). The police department has a Division of Internal Affairs (to monitor the police themselves); knowing this, it does not take long for Behrani to suspect that the tax office had not sent an armed policeman to interrogate him−surely this wouldn’t happen in the United States, where there is no SAVAK. After Lester’s visit as “Officer Gonzalez,” Behrani reasons that, since this is the United States, he shouldn’t expect the military to arrive on his doorstep in the dead of night, especially since Behrani hadn’t broken any rules. He had the $10,000 Bank of America check with him when he arrived at the auction; he then paid off the balance of the auctioned amount in full. He confirms his reasoning with a lawyer, who calls the Police Department for him, and then files a complaint at the Hall of Justice building.

The California police department’s Office of Internal Affairs contrasts with SAVAK, the Iranian Shah’s secret police. Behrani−who, it is intimated, maintained an extravagant lifestyle off the backs of his fellow Iranians−distances himself from the armed thugs who torture and kill others at someone’s whim (at least, he protests by socially snubbing General Pourat’s nephew). However, Behrani was sufficiently high on the imperial ladder (as Pourat had reminded him, he and SAVAK were on the same side) to have his name placed on the ayatollahs’ “death list.”The rule of law is also contrasted with the law of the mob: Behrani frequently remembers his old friend and commanding officer, General Pourat, hanging from his feet above the tarmac, blood still dripping from his sleeves, his murdered family around him. Since the Shah’s regime was the puppet government of the United States, it is expected that Behrani became a U.S. citizen after having been granted asylum by the U.S. government.

And, as the reader discovers, the rule of the mob is not necessarily different in effect than even trained police officers wanting to do good (but who are as error−prone as the rest of humankind). It is not just SAVAK that contrasts with the California legal system: Behrani frequently remembers the murder of his cousin Jasmeen (by her father’s gun, held down by her elder brother, for having had anaffair with a U.S. oil executive, a scandal which became public knowledge). Although Behrani hated his uncle for murdering Jasmeen, no one punished the uncle: at that time, it was his right to do so in Iran, to preserve the honor of the family name. Behrani strikes his wife Nadereh on several occasions, though he does not though take pleasure in it (and tells his son Esmail that doing so is wrong and to not behave like him).

There is also the California domestic violence law described by Lester: a woman defending herself with her fists against a man trying to stab her with a knife would also be charged. Although Behrani thinks at one point that he has killed Kathy, he does so only because Lester loves her. And, ironically, he, at least at some level, kills his wife because he really loves her, as he had loved his son Esmail. The author contrasts the California legal system with past imperialism of the U.S. federal government in the form of the rule of the Shaw of Iran; Jasmeen’s affair with a U.S. oil executive; Behrani’s gun, a gift from a U.S. defense contractor; Lester’s wife Carol’s college passion to travel the world with a camera and notebook to document American imperialism wherever she found it; and Pourat’s nephew, who said he learned the best techniques−dismembering children in front of their parents−in the U.S.

The American Dream and JusticeJustice does not prevail in this novel, because no amount of good intentions suffice. Lester muddles through Part II of the book, blinded initially by his love for Kathy and later, at least in part, from lack of sleep and anger at the chasm between Kathy’s and Behrani’s relative capitol assets. He is blinded ultimately though, because he is a military man: for example, he fears the Colonel isn’t taking him seriously; he didn’t think the Colonel’s pride would allow this to slide; he doesn’t move out of Behrani’s line of vision when he’s parallel parking because doing so would be simple courtesy.

Some might deem it poetic justice where this Iranian military man was terrorized, although he had done nothing wrong: his fate was not totally dissimilar to those attracting SAVAK’s attention, and he apparently lived ostentatiously at the expense of others (in the general way that totalitarian countries function, with the few dictating allmaterial rewards to the many). Behrani also at one time wonders whether his fate is not the inevitable consequence of his life near the top of the imperial heap. Some would deem the events that unfold horrifyingly in Part II of the book to be “mischance”: Behrani bought the house because it was up for auction, not to hurt Kathy. He had the cash and knew it was a good deal. Kathy overdosed on sleeping pills, because they were available in the medicine cabinet.

The officers shooting Esmail did not know the gun he was holding was not loaded. Some would attribute the lack of justice to bureaucratic ineptitude: Behrani would have never purchased the house if San Mateo County had not erroneously auctioned it off for back−taxes, and Kathy would not have been evicted from what was rightly hers. Both have a legal and legitimate claim to the Corona street house. In the sense that the function of the rule of law is to arbitrate in conflicts (which this most certainly is), Lester’s suggestion would have been brilliant had he thought of it sooner (his idea was that Behrani sell the house back to San Mateo County, which admitted its error, for the full amount he paid, and sign the check over to Kathy, who would then give him clear deed to the house). It was a legal compromise that could have worked, but things went so wrong.

Andre Dubus Iii's House Of Sand And Fog

Andre Dubus III's House of Sand and Fog

"House of Sand and Fog," by Andre Dubus III, explores the catastrophic repercussions of a complex misunderstanding between three characters. The conflict initially involves a dispute between Kathy Nicolo and Massoud Behrani over the “rightful” ownership of a house. The county wrongfully evicts Kathy and Behrani then buys her house at an auction. When Deputy Sheriff Lester Burdon enters the situation, events quickly slip out of control. Superficially, Lester’s character is important to the novel because he acts as a catalyst, propelling the plot into unexpected action. But Lester impacts the novel in a more profound way, because were it not for his insecurity and selfishness, the rest of the characters could have been spared an avoidable tragedy.

Lester’s commitment to help Kathy at all costs undeniably alters the outcome of the novel. By providing her with money for a motel, and later with shelter at a friend’s cabin, he allows her to continue avoiding the reality of the situation. If Lester had never met Kathy, she would have been forced to be upfront with her lawyer. Instead, Kathy tells herself “there a limit to how much [her lawyer] wants to help,” and continues to tell Connie Walsh that she is staying with friends (88). Knowing the severity of Kathy’s plight could have prompted Connie Walsh to more ardently pursue the county on Kathy’s behalf. Because of Lester, however, the truth is kept from the lawyer.

Additionally, although proclaiming his love for her, Lester becomes a negative influence on Kathy. Under the false sense of security he provides, Kathy, a recovering alcoholic, allows herself to start drinking again after an abstinence of three years. Though Lester’s concern for the return of her house is evident through his later actions, his concern for her psychological well-being seems non-existent. He never questions her sudden return to alcohol and fails to notice her growing dependence on it. If Lester had caught the warning signs—Kathy smoking profusely “as a crutch” and feeling “jittery” when she needs more alcohol—if Lester had recognized these symptoms, perhaps he would have realized Kathy’s current mental instability (145). But Lester overlooks this side of Kathy and is unable to check her usage. As a result, drunk and desperate at a restaurant in the mall, Kathy is convinced that Lester will return to his family and leave her, only after making love “to [her] like a man taking in oxygen before he goes on a long underwater trip” (202). In her impaired state, Kathy drives to her father’s house, now occupied by the Behrani family, and attempts suicide twice. When Lester arrives at the house and spies Kathy passed out on the floor, he assumes the worst and breaks into the Behrani’s house, holding them hostage. This starts a chain of events that ends with the Behranis and their son dead and Kathy and Lester in prison.

Lester’s presence...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Analysis of Killings by Andre Dubus

1130 words - 5 pages The major theme of Andre Dubus’ Killing,s is how far someone would go for the person they love. It is important to note the title of the story is killings and not killers, for the reasoning that the story does not just focus on two deaths or two murderers but rather the death of marriage, friendship, youth, and overall, trust. Richard Strout was married to Mary Ann, who was most likely fed up with his hot temperedness that always seemed to get...

Family relationships in fiction- Flannery O'Connor, William Faulkner, and Andre Dubus

1070 words - 4 pages Family Relationships in FictionFamily relationships played an integral part in the writings of Flannery O'Connor, William Faulkner, and Andre Dubus. Each author showed the importance of family in situations that the characters encountered. In "A Good Man...

Escaping the fog of "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen

1029 words - 4 pages The words of the title of Jane Austen's novel, Pride and Prejudice, shroud the main characters, Elizabeth and Darcy in a fog. The plot of the novel focuses on how Elizabeth and Darcy escape the fog and...

The Role of Vegetation in Coastal Development in Sand Dunes and Salt Marshes

1755 words - 7 pages The Role of Vegetation in Coastal Development in Sand Dunes and Salt Marshes (a) Sand Dunes Before considering the role of vegetation In the development of coastal sand dunes, it may be useful to summarise the general conditions which are conducive to dune formation In order to place the biological processes involved in a broader context. Factors which encourage dune formation include prevailing onshore winds blowing ...

Censorship in the 1950's: How did this affect the making of “Night and Fog” one of the first ever cinematic documentaries on the Holocaust? A film by

1063 words - 4 pages Censorship in the 1950's: How did this affect the making of “Night and Fog” one of the first ever cinematic documentaries on the Holocaust? A film by Alain Resnais. The ‘Night and Fog Decree’ was issued by Adolf Hitler on December 7th 1941. The ‘Night and Fog Decree’ (Nacht und Nebel Erlass) bypassed all forms of basic law and was an order from Hitler to his secret police to murder anyone in Nazi Germany and occupied Europe who was deemed to be...

Compare and contrast the ways "Regeneration" by Pat Barker and "The Rights of Desire" by Andre Brink deal with the theme of Love

1173 words - 5 pages Love is the least understandable human feeling. Love appears in all kinds of forms during most novels studied in class. However love is very difficult to categorize, some correlations can be made between 'types' of love and between the characters of different novels. In "The Rights of Desire" and "Regeneration", this is the case. Admiration, sexual attraction, respect and love in the family are seen and dealt with in different ways. In...

The House of Bernarda Alba and A Doll's House

1609 words - 6 pages Federico Garcia Lorca's “The House of Bernarda Alba” and Henrik Ibsen's “A Doll's House” both protest against the confinement of women of their days. Although the Houses are set differently in Spain of 20th century and Norway of 19th century respectively, both the plays relate in illuminating their respective female protagonists, Adela and Nora, as they eventually develop a sense of individuality and self-expression, emerging as free individuals...

A Doll's House and the House of Bernarda Alba

1070 words - 4 pages Federico Garcia Lorca's “The House of Bernarda Alba” and Henrik Ibsen's “A Doll's House” both protest against the confinement of women of their days. Although the Houses are set differently in Spain of 20th century and Norway of 19th century respectively, both the plays relate in illuminating their respective female protagonists, Adela and Nora, as they eventually develop a sense of individuality and self-expression and emerge as free individuals...

Comparison Of "The Boarding House" And "Araby"

778 words - 3 pages Comparison of "The Boarding House" and "Araby" James Joyce wrote a collection of short stories that can be found published as Dubliners. An observant reader may notice a trend throughout these stories. They are stories of frustration and escape...

Comparison of A Doll's House and Antigone

1517 words - 6 pages “The Empowered Woman, she moves through the world with a sense of confidence and grace. Her once reckless spirit now tempered by wisdom. Quietly, yet firmly, she speaks her truth without doubt or hesitation and the life she leads is of her own creation.” --Excerpt from ‘The Empowered Woman’ by Sonny Carroll In my mind, Sonny Carroll’s poem perfectly represents what an empowered woman should be; firm, determined and able to...

Analysing the sub text in two documentaries- Michael Moore's "Bowling for Columbine" and Errol Morris's" Fog of War", and a comparison of the directorial style of the two filmmakers.

1009 words - 4 pages Analysing sub text in "Bowling for Columbine", Michael Moore.The very first shot of the film is that of Charlton Heston promoting it, as a documentary the American Rifle...

0 thoughts on “House Of Sand And Fog Essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *